· · 5 min read
Tub Grinder vs Horizontal Grinder: 7 Key Differences
Tub grinder vs horizontal grinder comes down to feed style: tub grinders swallow bulky storm debris and whole trees at 30 to 100 tons per hour with coarse output, while horizontal grinders meter-feed logs and pallets at 20 to 80 tons per hour with uniform 15 to 75 mm product. Tub units cost $280000 to $650000, horizontals $320000 to $750000, and running costs differ by $1 to $3 per ton. This 7-point tub grinder vs horizontal grinder comparison covers working principles, specs, costs, and which fits your material.
Key Takeaways
- Tub grinders use a rotating tub (10 to 14 ft diameter) for bulky tops and storm wood; horizontals use a feed conveyor for logs and pallets.
- Throughput overlaps at 20 to 100 T/h, but tubs surge 20 percent higher in fluffy debris while horizontals hold tighter sizing.
- Horizontal output is more uniform at 15 to 75 mm with fines below 8 percent versus 10 to 20 percent for tubs.
- Purchase prices differ by 10 to 20 percent; fuel per ton runs $4 to $9 for both at 500-plus HP.
- Choose tub for land clearing and storm cleanup, horizontal for biomass fuel and colored mulch contracts.
How Does Each Machine Work?
A tub grinder drops material into a 10 to 14 ft diameter rotating tub that gravity-feeds a hammermill below. The operator dumps whole trees, stumps, and storm piles with a grapple in 2 to 5 ton bites, and the tub rotation meters flow. Changeover between 2 screen sizes takes 30 to 60 minutes with a loader assist.
A horizontal grinder feeds material on a 20 to 32 ft infeed conveyor past a press roll into the rotor. Logs, pallets, and mill waste meter evenly at 1 to 3 ft per second, giving steady rotor load and 15 to 25 percent better fuel per ton in uniform wood. Metal contamination is easier to manage because the infeed magnet sees a thin single layer.
Both use 20 to 48 hammers and 2 to 6 screen segments, and both are covered by WeiDong Machinery with 12-month or 2000-hour warranty. Compare layouts on our tub grinder page and horizontal grinder page.
What Are the 7 Key Differences?
| Factor | Tub Grinder | Horizontal Grinder |
|---|---|---|
| Feed style | 10 to 14 ft tub, grapple-dumped bulky piles | 20 to 32 ft conveyor, metered logs and pallets |
| Best material | Storm debris, whole trees, stumps | Pallets, logs, mill waste, biomass |
| Throughput | 30 to 100 T/h, surges well in fluffy tops | 20 to 80 T/h, steadier in uniform wood |
| Output uniformity | 25 to 100 mm, fines 10 to 20 percent | 15 to 75 mm, fines under 8 percent |
| Contamination tolerance | High — tub absorbs dirt and odd shapes | Medium — press roll prefers cleaner feed |
| Mobility and footprint | Taller 13 to 15 ft transport height, needs crane | Lower profile, faster 1-day setup |
| Price band | $280000 to $650000 | $320000 to $750000 |
In practice the gap is narrowest at 30 to 50 T/h in clean logs, where either machine works. The gap widens above 60 T/h in storm wood (tub wins) and in 20 mm biomass fuel (horizontal wins). If your mix is 50-50, price both from WeiDong Machinery on identical per-ton terms.
How Do Costs Compare?
Five cost lines decide, not sticker price alone:
- Purchase price — tubs run 10 to 20 percent cheaper at equal HP; a 600 HP tub at $420000 versus $480000 horizontal.
- Wear parts — $5 to $10 per ton for tubs in dirty wood versus $4 to $8 for horizontals in cleaner feed.
- Fuel — both burn 25 to 55 liters per hour at full load, or $4 to $9 per ton at 40 to 80 T/h.
- Labor — 1 grapple operator plus 1 loader driver for either; horizontals need 1 extra sorter for metal at $25 to $40 per hour.
- Downtime — tub tub-drive chains and horizontal press rolls each cost $6000 to $15000 per failure every 3000 to 5000 hours.
Over 5 years at 1500 hours per year, the lifetime gap is usually under $80000 — smaller than one wrong screen choice. Get a 5-year per-ton quote from our sales team for both layouts.
Which Fits Your Material?
Follow these 4 picks used by our application engineers across 200-plus installations:
- Storm debris and land clearing — tub grinder; swallows 30 ft trees and root balls without pre-cutting, saving 2 to 3 processing steps.
- Biomass and pellet fuel at 20 to 30 mm — horizontal grinder; holds fines below 8 percent and passes fuel audits first time.
- Colored mulch at 30 to 50 mm — horizontal grinder for uniform dye uptake; tub acceptable for natural mulch only.
- Mixed C and D waste with metal — tub grinder with magnetic head pulley removes 90 percent of tramp metal at high surge rates.
Contractors running 2 to 4 sites per year often pair a 600 HP tub for clearing with a 400 HP horizontal for fuel yards, sharing $20000 of screen and hammer stock. Either way, standard models ship in 15 to 30 days with export packing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between tub grinder and horizontal grinder?
The tub uses a rotating 10 to 14 ft tub for bulky dump-fed debris, while the horizontal uses a 20 to 32 ft conveyor for metered logs and pallets. Horizontals give more uniform 15 to 75 mm output; tubs surge higher in storm wood.
Which one should I buy for land clearing?
Buy a tub grinder for land clearing and storm cleanup at 30 to 100 T/h. Buy a horizontal grinder for biomass fuel, mulch, and pallet contracts needing fines below 8 percent.
How much do they cost?
Tubs cost $280000 to $650000 and horizontals $320000 to $750000 new, with used units 35 to 60 percent cheaper at 2500 to 4500 hours. Running costs run $4 to $10 per ton all-in.
Can one machine do both jobs?
Yes at 20 to 50 T/h in mixed yards with 2 screen sets, but dedicated machines win above 60 T/h or below 25 mm fuel specs. A 2-person screen change takes 30 to 60 minutes.
Next Step
Send WeiDong Machinery your material photos, target output size, and weekly tonnage for a tub-versus-horizontal recommendation with ex-works prices for both. Compare the tub grinder lineup and horizontal grinder lineup, or message our sales team — replies arrive within one business day.